Ally vs. Barclays Savings: Which Pays More?
Barclays Tiered Savings pays more than Ally at every balance and adds a $200 bonus; Ally has buckets, round ups and checking at the same bank. Rates, fees and safety compared.
How we make money: Some links on this page may earn us a commission. That never affects our scores or the order of our picks, which follow our published methodology. Advertiser disclosure
Barclays pays more: its Tiered Savings account earns 3.50% APY on balances under $250,000 and 3.65% from $250,000, while Ally Bank pays 3.20% APY on every balance. Both have no minimum and no monthly fees. Pick Ally if you want savings buckets, round ups and checking at the same bank; pick Barclays for the higher rate and a $200 bonus on $25,000 of new money. Ally rate as of Oct 27, 2026; Barclays rate as of Oct 7, 2026; both checked at the banks on Oct 27, 2026.
Ally and Barclays are two of the best known online savings banks in the US, and both are simple: no minimum, no monthly fee, one account you manage in an app. The real differences are the rate, the tools and what else the bank offers.
Ally vs. Barclays savings at a glance
| Ally Bank Savings | Barclays Tiered Savings | |
|---|---|---|
| APY | 3.20% on all balances | 3.50% under $250,000; 3.65% from $250,000 to $1,000,000 |
| Rate as of | Oct 27, 2026 | Oct 7, 2026 |
| Minimum to open | $0 | $0 |
| Monthly fee | None | None |
| Bonus | None listed | $200 for $25,000 of new money within 30 days, kept 120 days (ends Jan 31, 2027) |
| Savings tools | Buckets and boosters such as round ups | Basic savings |
| Withdrawal limit | 10 certain withdrawals and transfers per statement cycle | See Barclays account terms |
| Checking at the same bank | Yes, with spending buckets | No; Barclays US offers savings and CDs only |
| App rating (App Store) | 4.7 | 4.9 |
| FDIC insured through | Ally Bank (certificate 57803) | Barclays Bank Delaware (certificate 57203) |
From Ally’s and Barclays’ savings pages and the App Store, checked Oct 27, 2026. Rates are variable. Barclays also offers Online Savings at 3.20% APY (as of Oct 7, 2026); Tiered Savings pays more at every balance.
How much more does Barclays pay?
| Balance | Ally (one year) | Barclays (one year) |
|---|---|---|
| $10,000 | $320 | $350 |
| $25,000 | $800 | $875 |
| $100,000 | $3,200 | $3,500 |
Interest over one year if the APY stays the same and nothing is withdrawn. Live rates from our checks.
On $250,000 or more, Barclays’ rate rises to 3.65% APY, about $9,125 a year on $250,000. If you move $25,000 or more of new money, the $200 bonus widens the gap in year one.
Why you might still pick Ally
- Buckets: split one savings account into goals, such as an emergency fund and a vacation, without opening more accounts.
- Boosters: round ups and other tools move small amounts into savings automatically.
- Everything at one bank: Ally also has a spending account with its own buckets, so transfers between checking and savings are internal. Barclays US has no checking, so you move money to and from another bank.
The trade off is the rate, and Ally’s limit of 10 certain withdrawals and transfers per statement cycle.
Is either the best savings account?
No. Both trail the top accounts we track. The highest rate with no monthly rules right now is Pibank Savings at 4.40% APY. If rate is what matters most, compare the best high yield savings accounts. If you value a big, established bank, both Ally and Barclays are solid choices.
Are Ally and Barclays safe?
Yes. Ally Bank (FDIC certificate 57803, Sandy, Utah) holds about $188.2 billion in assets, and Barclays Bank Delaware (certificate 57203, Wilmington, Delaware) about $43.5 billion (June 30, 2026, FDIC). Deposits at each are insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category. Read is Barclays bank legit? for more on Barclays.
Frequently asked questions
Does Ally or Barclays pay more on savings?
Barclays. Its Tiered Savings account pays more than Ally’s savings account at every balance, and 3.65% APY from $250,000. Both rates were checked at the banks on Oct 27, 2026.
Do Ally or Barclays savings accounts have fees or minimums?
Neither has a minimum to open or a monthly fee.
Does Barclays have a savings bonus?
Yes. Barclays pays $200 if you deposit at least $25,000 within 30 days of opening Tiered Savings and keep $25,000 for 120 days. The offer expires Jan 31, 2027. Ally does not list a savings bonus.
Does Barclays have checking?
No. Barclays US offers savings and CDs only. Ally offers a spending account alongside its savings account.
Are Ally and Barclays FDIC insured?
Yes. Ally Bank is FDIC certificate 57803 and Barclays Bank Delaware is certificate 57203, each insured up to $250,000 per depositor, per ownership category.
Compare today’s top savings rates
Happen Bank LevelUp SavingsAPY as of Oct 23, 20264.20%with $250 or more in deposits each monthReview →
